Dont forget, when you join the the bart ehrman blog, membership includes access to a very active discussions forum password secured for members only. While this does not mean that carrier is correct it does, in my opinion, make it worthy of discussion. Er war mehrjahrig fur internet infidels als chefredakteur tatig. This task is complicated because, in his response to my original piece, carrier says a surprisingly small amount that engages my argument and a large amount that does not.
The book might mark not cause a change in collective perception from a historical to a mythical jesus. The religion of jesus christ stands or falls upon the events of history. Carrier speak on the historicity of jesus doesnt prepare you for the academic onslaught of this book. Celsus charged that christs own people killed him, and that his resurrection was a deception. A quote from atheist historian richard carrier s book on the historicity of jesus even before christianity arose, some jews expected one of their messiahs. Richard carriers book argues for a bayesian, probabilistic interpretation of historiography in general and of the debate about the historicity of. Imagine in your golden years you are accused of murdering a child many decades ago and put on trial for it. Proving history, on the failure of methodology in the study of jesus and how to fix it. Carrier rigidly applies the logic of bayes theorem to the evidence for the historicity of jesus and finds no reason to conclude he actually existed. Jan 16, 2015 a first reaction on richard carrier on the historicity of jesus i have not completed reading richard carrier on the historicity of jesus. Mar 30, 2016 while this does not mean that carrier is correct it does, in my opinion, make it worthy of discussion. I have just read it and highly recommend it as an excellent informed analysis of current scholarship on this topic. I have not completed reading richard carrier on the historicity of jesus.
Questioning the plausibility of jesus ahistoricity theories. In one passage he called jesus the christ, referred to his marvelous deeds, and alluded to his death and resurrection 18. Jul 02, 2015 topics range from the historicity of jesus to how we do history anyways. A first reaction on richard carrier on the historicity of jesus. Mar 30, 2016 my interest in this thread is the latter, specifically i would like to discuss the relative merits of on the historicity of jesus, by dr. Syllabus class 49 jesus imagined history text below introduction the problem of jesus historicity should it matter to atheists and agnostics. On the historicity of jesus, a community discussion. In antiquities of the jews, the historian twice referred to jesus. Myth versus historythere is a strong possibility that the jesus of the new testament was not a historical person. However, despite the cmt being a minority viewpoint, there criticisms that exist in virtually every facet of the historicity of jesus that carrier can be cited in. The historicity of jesus christ by wayne jackson, m. It is called on the historicity of jesus, and is written by richard carrier. The actual scholarly research on the historicity of jesus is interesting and has been the subject of many books, but its very limited and doesnt do enough sleuthing into the metaphysical to get the bigger picture. What are some flaws in the argument proposed by richard.
Aca lecture series richard carrier september 27, 2014 topic. What are the most important criticisms of richard carriers. In the historical jesus hypotheses, jesus varies from a simple itinerate rabbi, to a zealot leader, to a philosopherteacher, etc. When you talk about a logically sound book on the historicity of jesus. Richard carrier on the historicity of jesus youtube. For you that may be visiting with us, i might say that we.
I havent read carrier s book, but ive heard him outline his theories in debate a few times. Its a real life detective story which leads you deep into the evidence. Three horses in the race christian historicity secular historicity secular non historicity jesus was an amazingly famous superman who could walk on water and shit. Carrier reexamines the whole question and finds compelling reasons to suspect the more daring assumption is correct.
The historicity of jesus is the question whether jesus of nazareth existed as a historical figure, whether any of the major milestones in his life as portrayed in the gospels can be confirmed as historical events as opposed to myth, legend, or fiction, and the weighing of the evidence relating to his life. I personally would like to make that evaluation by looking into the book itself. Millions of christians, perhaps billions, believe he was god incarnate. By simcha jacobovici in jesus archeology february 4, 2014. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The historicity of jesus historian and bible scholar, dr. Evaluating a key claim in richard carriers on the historicity of jesus. Richard cevantis carrier born december 1, 1969 is an american author and activist, whose work focuses on empiricism, atheism, and the historicity of jesus. At our postflaviana website, we do not mind returning the favor. Carrier concludes that with the bayesian method of reasoning, the probabilities of a historical jesus is being generous.
While the authors rigorous use of bayesian method makes this book a tough slog at times, it is difficult to imagine how it might be refuted. University of chicago press, 1912 christianity 352 pages. Questioning the plausibility of jesus ahistoricity theoriesa brief. Why we might have reason for doubt by richard carrier. While bart normally cannot moderate the forum due to limited time, it provides members the opportunity to bounce thoughts off each other, to discuss recent posts by bart, or any number of other insightful and topical discussions. Richard carrier if he exists is a jesus mythicist, someone who disbelieves in the existence of jesus of nazareth as a real person in space and time. He lays out extensive research on the evidence for jesus and the origins of christianity and poses the key questions that must now be answered if the historicity of jesus is to survive as a dominant paradigm. But celsus never questioned the historicity of jesus. If you follow tim oneill on quora, youll find many arguments against carrier. Nov 08, 2015 aca lecture series richard carrier september 27, 2014 topic.
My interest in this thread is the latter, specifically i would like to discuss the relative merits of on the historicity of jesus, by dr. Carrier chooses a minimal approach reducing both arguments to common denominators such that both camps can agree about their side of the argument. Why we might have reason for doubt by carrier, richard isbn. Why we might have reason for doubt sheffield phoenix press, 2014 by richard carrier. Carriers on the historicity of jesus made him the leading proponent of the christmyth theory. Those in the mythical camp have proposed that jesus was an invention stolen from pagan religions and sun gods to a son of god predicted by hebrew scripture, or a. An update on richard carriers book, on the historicity of. Richard carriers on the historicity of jesus free download as pdf file. Jesus was an ordinary nobody, whom no one noticed but a few fanatical followers. Applying a bayesian criterion propounded in his foundational book proving history, carrier methodically breaks down contemporary historiographical assumptions, and. A response to richard carriers on the historicity of jesus. Hopefully you will stick around on the thread and read the book and join us for the discussions on the historicity of jesus.
In the twilight zone of mythicism, that an event is assumed to have happened on earth unless otherwise stated is not the default position. Celsus argued that jesus was born in low circumstances, being the illegitimate son of a soldier named panthera see above. Its not certain, we dont have the documentation to make a 100% assertion for or against. The minimal theory of historicity and the minimal jesus myth theory, defined as follows. Both are well versed in the literature and make pretty cogent arguments. Recently, richard carriers work on the historicity of jesus sheffield phoenix press, 2014 has attempted to reexamine the question in a. You might like to also read a detailed systematic analysis of the actual language paul used about jesus. Some now agree historicity agnosticism is warranted, including arthur droge professor of early christianity at ucsd, kurt noll associate professor of religion at brandon university, and thomas thompson renowned professor of theology, emeritus, at the university of copenhagen. Richard carriers on the historicity of jesus bias of. Bayes theorem and the quest for the historical jesus amherst, ny. Richard carriers on the historicity of jesus bias of an. The christian church only obtained its mass political traction by rejecting such docetic ideas, even though they appear in paul, and instead insisting that jesus of nazareth was fully man.
A quote from atheist historian richard carriers book on the. Hebrews chapter 2, verses 9 through 18 is our text this morning. Born of a woman, christ myth debate, richard carrier. Christian historicity secular historicity secular non historicity jesus was an amazingly famous superman who could walk on water and shit. Hopefully you will stick around on the thread and read the book and join us. Which fact has resulted in the proliferation of endless different conclusions as to the nature of the historical jesus and the origins of christianity. Read the fulltext online edition of the historicity of jesus.
Will you turn with me, please, in your bibles to the 2nd chapter of hebrews. Feb 09, 2016 if you follow tim oneill on quora, youll find many arguments against carrier. Here, the cmt section is a minority viewpoint and doesnt necessitate the same level of detail as other sections. Additionally, carrier denies being a mythicist, though he argues there is good evidence for the strong mythicist case. Carrier has written on the historicity of jesus, proposing an origin of christianity without a historical jesus. Richard carrier on the historicity of jesus why we might have reason for doubt. Jun 01, 2014 on the historicity of jesus ohj is an exhaustive analysis of all extant evidence concerning the biblical jesus, ultimately offering sound reasons for doubt of jesus historicity. As he grew, he announced himself to be god, deceiving many. Three horses in the race christian historicity secular historicity secular nonhistoricity jesus was an amazingly famous superman who could walk on water and shit. An update on richard carriers book, on the historicity. A criticism of the contention that jesus never lived, a statement of the evidence for his existence, an. However, despite the cmt being a minority viewpoint, there criticisms that exist in virtually every facet of the historicity of jesus that carrier can be. A criticism of the contention that jesus never lived, a statement of the evidence for his existence, an estimate of his relation to christianity. Topics range from the historicity of jesus to how we do history anyways.
Why we might have reason for doubt the jesus myth theory is the view that the person. Should we never question the historicity of an ancient figure because it sounds funny misapplying similar criteria to a modern person. On the historicity of jesus quotes showing 110 of 10 this problem can be illustrated with a mock analogy. A quote from atheist historian richard carriers book on. The book might mark not cause a change in collective perception from. Jesus was the name of a celestial being, subordinate to god, with whom some people hallucinated conversations. The attempt to use later sources, interpreted in ways that are at best open to dispute, in an attempt to argue against what generations of skeptical scholars have concluded to be likely with respect to the early christian sources, is never. Which fact has resulted in the proliferation of endless different conclusions as to the nature of. What are the most important criticisms of richard carrier. The hypothesis that jesus never really existed has started to gain more credibility in the expert community. The hypothesis of historicity on the historicity of jesus by richard carrier robert tulip wrote. Some religions, both ancient and modern, require no historical basis, for they depend upon ideas rather than events. See also the what is the directory structure for the texts. I havent read carriers book, but ive heard him outline his theories in debate a few times.
Richard carrier promotes his new book the historicity of jesus. Why we might have reason for doubt kindle edition by carrier, richard. Imagine in your golden years you are accused of murdering a. A first reaction on richard carrier on the historicity of. Proving history requires improving methods several examinations of the methodologies employed in the study of jesus have consistently found those methods invalid or defective. I would like to provide responses to the arguments and evidence that richard carrier offers to rebut my argument that jesus existed. The hypothesis of historicity on the historicity of. Yet i have read enough to advise you to consider it. Richard carriers on the historicity of jesus click the start the download.
Questioning the plausibility of jesus ahistoricity. Why we might have reason for doubt carrier, richard on. Biblical scholars, biblical studies, new testament tags. Jesus of nazareth remains one of the most enigmatic figures whos ever lived. On the historicity of jesus ohj is an exhaustive analysis of all extant evidence concerning the biblical jesus, ultimately offering sound reasons for doubt of jesus historicity. Soif jesus didnot exist, where did he come from then. Richard carrier on the historicity of jesus milwaukee atheists. This work is licensed under a creative commons attribution 4. Criticisms ive heard about carriers theory, from tim and elsewhere im. Jun 03, 2014 when you talk about a logically sound book on the historicity of jesus. The earliest nonchristian testimony to the lords existence is that of the jewish historian, flavius josephus a.
1081 968 1124 150 982 655 270 303 673 842 857 836 135 581 371 1433 835 885 396 1440 396 1202 636 300 266 913 1301 1211 956 748 65 1105 3 529 386 916